Blog
Law Offices of Chance M. McGhee

Call Today for a FREE Consultation

210-342-3400

Archive for the ‘judgments’ tag

Chapter 13 with a Judgment Lien, HOA Lien, or Child/Spousal Support

December 6th, 2017 at 8:00 am

Chapter 13 can work much better than Chapter 7 if you have a judgment or HOA lien on your home, or get behind on child or spousal support.  


You may need the extra help of Chapter 13 if you have any of the following liens against your home:

  • Judgment lien
  • Homeowner association lien
  • Unpaid child or spousal support

Or you may not need that extra help. Two blog posts ago we showed scenarios where Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” could handle these situations well. If you’re current on your mortgage but have any of these three issues, check out that earlier blog post.

But even if you are current on your first mortgage, if you do have any of these 3 debts/liens in some circumstances Chapter 13 could definitely be better for you. Today we show you how.

Judgment Liens

When we got into judgment liens two blog posts ago, we ended by saying that having a judgment (or “judicial”) lien is not a deciding factor in choosing between Chapter 7 and 13. That’s because judgment lien “avoidance” is available under both, with the same rules for qualifying for it. (That’s in contrast to a number of legal benefits only available under Chapter 13.)

However, getting rid of (“avoiding”) a judgment lien may be procedurally easier under Chapter 13. And arguably the judgment creditor is less likely to respond and object.

To avoid a judgment lien in Chapter 7 your bankruptcy lawyer has to file a Motion for Avoidance of Lien. It’s filed at bankruptcy court along with a formal Notice of that Motion. For example, see these Local Bankruptcy Forms 717 and 717.05. Both have to be formally served on the judgment creditor. So the creditor receives these documents that no other creditor receives.

In contrast, under Chapter 13 the judgment lien avoidance language is buried within the multi-page proposed payment plan. See page 4 of the bankruptcy court’s 8-page Official Form 113 Chapter 13 Plan. All creditors receive a copy of this proposed plan. So, there’s more of a tendency for a judgment creditor to not notice the lien avoidance. And if it does notice, it’s more likely to just shrug it away if the resulting unsecured debt is being paid anything under the plan.

(Please see our earlier blog post for the rules about qualifying for judgment lien avoidance, applicable to both Chapters. Also see the applicable Section 522(f)(1)(A) of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code.)

Homeowner Association Lien

Homeowner association liens are special, and especially dangerous, for a number of reasons. In certain circumstances they can be superior to your mortgage lender’s lien. (That means it comes ahead of the mortgage itself on your home’s title.) State laws differ but generally HOAs have unusually aggressive collection powers. So you need be especially attentive if you fall behind on your HOA dues or assessments. Doing so can result in serious risks for your home, both from the HOA and your mortgage lender.                          

You can protect yourself from those risks much better in a Chapter 13 case. In a Chapter 7 case, if you’re behind on any HOA obligation you essentially have to work it out with your HOA. And you may well have to placate your mortgage lender at the same time. You don’t have much leverage with either.

In contrast, in a Chapter 13 case you and your home are protected while you catch up on your HOA arrearage. You do need to keep current on any ongoing dues and/or assessment payments. But as far as the past-due payments, you’d generally have up to 5 years to bring them current. As long as you stick to the court-approved payment plan you won’t have to worry about the HOA. Nor your lender.

Child/Spousal Support

In most circumstances, being behind on support creates a lien against your home. (This is usually the result of the legal judgment arising out of your divorce decree).

Filing a Chapter 7 case doesn’t freeze the collection actions of any support obligations. The “automatic stay” is the usual protection from creditor collections during bankruptcy. There is an exception in the “automatic stay” for the collection of support. See Section 362(b)(2) of the Bankruptcy Code.

However, filing a Chapter 13 case DOES freeze the collection of PAST-DUE support. (The collection of ongoing monthly support payments can continue, but you’d want to pay those anyway.) Because support collections can be extraordinarily aggressive, this can be a crucial benefit of Chapter 13. You DO need to fastidiously keep current on any ongoing support, and maintain your Chapter 13 commitments. But as long as you do so you’d have up to 5 years to get current on the past-due support.

 

Chapter 7 with a Judgment Lien, HOA Debt, or Support Obligations

December 1st, 2017 at 8:00 am

Here are 3 more scenarios for when you are current on your mortgage, where Chapter 7 works well in dealing with other home-related debts.


Our last blog post was about situations in which Chapter 7 works well enough in the following 3 debt situations:

  1. Second or third mortgages
  2. Property taxes
  3. Income tax with a lien recorded on your home

In general, if you are current on your first mortgage but have any of these 3 debts, sometimes Chapter 13 helps much more than Chapter 7. But last time we showed scenarios when you don’t need the extra time and expense of Chapter 13.

We do the same today with the following 3 other home-related types of debts:

1. Judgment with a lien attached to your home

2. Homeowner association debt with a lien

3. Child/spousal support unpaid with a lien

Judgment Liens

In bankruptcy you can often remove a lien on your home arising from a creditor’s judgment against you. That’s important because otherwise the lien would continue on your home’s title even after you discharge (legally write off) the underlying debt.

Whether you can remove, or “avoid,” the judgment lien depends on the value of your home, the amount of its equity, and amount of your applicable homestead exemption. If all of the judgment lien “impairs,” or cuts into, your homestead exemption, you can remove that lien.

For example, assume your home is worth $200,000, you owe $175,000 on the mortgage, so you have $25,000 in equity. Your state’s homestead exemption is $30,000, covering all of your equity and more. You have a judgment lien on your home’s title in the amount of $10,000. All of that $10,000 cuts into the equity that’s protected by your $30,000 homestead exemption. So you can “avoid,” or remove the entire judgment lien in bankruptcy.

There are some tools affecting liens that are available only in Chapter 13, not in Chapter 7. This is not one of them. You can “avoid” a judgment lien under the same rules in either Chapter 7 or 13. So this is not a deciding factor between these two bankruptcy options.

Homeowner Association Lien

State laws differ on homeowner association liens. But in general not being current on your HOA dues and/or assessments can be a significant problem. It can catch you by surprise. So be sure to tell your bankruptcy lawyer if you are paying HOA dues or assessments. Of course be sure to tell if you are not current on them.

One of the reasons these liens are dangerous is that under some circumstances they are superior to your mortgage on your title. Falling behind is likely an independent basis for foreclosure by your mortgage lender—even if you’re current on the mortgage itself. Also, the timetable for action by your HOA may be quick compared to a home lender’s foreclosure.

If you have monthly HOA dues and you’re current on them, and intend to stay in the home, filing a Chapter 7 case should be fine.

But if you’re at all behind with your HOA and don’t have an agreed payment plan to catch up, talk with your lawyer about your options, including Chapter 13. You’d very likely have more time and flexibility in catching up and keeping your home protected while doing so.

Child/Spousal Support

Often, being behind on support creates a lien against your home. That may even happen when you’re current (through the judgment arising out of your divorce decree).

Filling a Chapter 7 case should be fine if you are current on all support obligations at time of filing. If you are not current but expect to be very shortly thereafter, be aware that filing a Chapter 7 case does NOT freeze the collection actions of any support obligations—neither ongoing monthly ones nor those in arrears.

However, Chapter 13 CAN stop the collection of support obligations that are in arrears. Those collections can be unusually aggressive—sometimes resulting in even the loss of your driver’s license, or possibly your occupational or professional license. So knowing that Chapter 13 can freeze collections and buy you time to catch up is important. If this debt is causing you serious problems this may be reason enough to choose Chapter 13.

 

Chapter 7 Prevents Judgment Liens on Your Home

November 13th, 2017 at 8:00 am

Filing a Chapter 7 case stops foreclosure of your home temporarily, helping you gather funds for your transition to your next housing. 


Recently we went through a list of ways Chapter 7 buys you time when dealing with debts affecting your home. Included was that filing a Chapter 7 case can “stop a lawsuit from turning into a judgment lien.” That judgment lien could turn a debt that you wouldn’t have to pay after bankruptcy into one you would. That’s certainly a result you want to avoid.

Some judgment liens against your home can be “avoided”—or undone– in bankruptcy. Then maybe you wouldn’t have to pay the underlying debt. But some judgment liens can’t be “avoided.” The debt behind such a lien would therefore have to be paid, even after filing bankruptcy. Again, that’s a result you really want to avoid.

In those situations filing a Chapter 7 case before there’s a judgment usually prevents that bad result. Let’s dig into this more to better understand it.

Lawsuits by Conventional Creditors

If you’re thinking about bankruptcy the judgments you mostly likely need to be worrying about are those by creditors. By “creditors” we mean conventional ones like those you might owe for credit cards, medical bills, a repossessed vehicle, personal loans, and such.

Lawsuits by such creditors often don’t leave you with much defense. You concede owing the money you’ve contracted to pay, haven’t paid, so usually (but not always) you have no defense. The creditor will get a judgment by default against you if you don’t respond to the lawsuit in time.

Less Conventional Creditors

But you might also be involved in other kinds of legal disputes potentially resulting in a judgment against you. That could arise from just about anything. A few examples would be:

  • a vehicle accident with a dispute about fault, damages, or insurance coverage
  • an injury to someone on your property that for some reason isn’t covered by your homeowner’s or renter’s insurance
  • a disagreement with a contractor or other service provider on repairs to your home
  • a dispute with family members about the proceeds of a deceased relative’s estate
  • a disagreement with your business’ investor, co-founder, employee, supplier, or its commercial landlord

It’s not unusual for people involved in such disputes to file bankruptcy if such litigation is not going well. They have much financially riding on wining the lawsuit. Then when it becomes clear that’s not happening they desparately need to cut their losses.

Filing Bankruptcy Prevents a Judgment against You

Whether with conventional creditor lawsuits or these other kinds of disputes, the timing of your bankruptcy filing is crucial. It has to be filed in time to prevent the lawsuit from turning into a judgment, and then into a judgment lien against your home.

So when dealing with a conventional creditor lawsuit, your bankruptcy lawyer generally needs to file your Chapter 7 case in bankruptcy court before your deadline to file the formal answer to the creditor’s complaint in the state court. (There are also likely other more expensive ways to prevent a default judgment from being entered against you.)

When dealing with ongoing litigation, talk with your lawyer about when you’d have to file bankruptcy to prevent entry of a judgment.

Judgments and Judgment Liens

State laws differ about what it takes for a creditor who gets a judgment against you to turn that into a judgment lien against your home. This may take an extra procedure. Or it may happen simultaneously with the court’s entry of the judgment. Again, talk with your lawyer. But in most situations, the judgment lien can happen very fast after the judgment, if not at the same time. So, for practical purposes, you’re going to want to file bankruptcy before the entry of the judgment.

Next: Avoidable vs. Unavoidable Judgment Liens

If you already have a judgment lien against your home, don’t despair. As we said in the first couple paragraphs, bankruptcy allows you to “avoid” some judgment liens against your home. In our next blog post we’ll distinguish between judgments that can and can’t be “avoided”—or undone—in bankruptcy.

 

Execution Liens, Judgments on Nondischargeable Debts

January 11th, 2017 at 8:00 am

Execution liens on your home are like judgment liens, “avoidable” in bankruptcy. But only if the underlying debt can be discharged.  


The last three blog posts have been about judgment liens on your home. We explained the trouble they cause, how bankruptcy can often get rid of them, and gave examples of both. Today we mention a couple of important twists to round out this topic of judgment liens.

Judgment Liens and Execution Liens

We’ve talked about getting rid of judgment liens without saying anything about execution liens.

“Execution lien” is a less commonly heard term. It’s used more often in certain states.

An execution lien usually arises when a creditor sues you, gets a judgment (usually because you don’t respond to the summons), then the creditor gets a writ of execution in order to collect on the judgment, and finally records the execution wherever your deed is recorded. 

The details of this procedure vary from state to state. For example, in some states the entry of the judgment itself creates a lien on real estate in that county. In other states this depends on the court in which the judgment was obtained, sometimes requiring a separate docketing of the judgment in the land records. Or sometimes the creditor needs a recorded writ of execution after getting a judgment, in order to get a lien on your home.

Execution Liens are “Judicial Liens”

Simply put, whether a lien placed on your home is called a judgment lien or an execution lien likely does not matter for purposes of getting out from that lien in bankruptcy.

We have been using the term “judgment lien.” But the actual broader term used in the Bankruptcy Code is “judicial lien.” The U.S. Bankruptcy Code says that “the debtor may avoid [that is, undo] the fixing of a lien… if such lien is—a judicial lien.” Section 522(f)(1)(A).

A “judicial lien” is a “lien obtained by judgment, levy, sequestration, or other legal or equitable process or proceeding.” Section 101(36) of the Bankruptcy Code. That broad language makes quite clear that it doesn’t matter whether you are dealing with something called a judgment lien or execution lien. Either one is a judicial lien which can potentially be “avoided” from the title of your home.

See our post of last Friday about how that’s done.

Judicial Liens on Non-Dischargeable Debts

In that same recent blog post, we gave a list of conditions for “avoiding” a judgment/ judicial lien. But we didn’t specifically list one crucial condition because we figured it was self-explanatory. However we realize this needs to be made clearer.  

That one additional condition is that the debt which is the basis for the judgment against you must be a debt that can be discharged—written off—in bankruptcy. If you can’t discharge the underlying debt that led to the judgment, you can’t “avoid” the judicial lien resulting from it.

Take the example of a debt for a criminal restitution. A court orders somebody to pay $30,000 in restitution because of his or her embezzlement. The court would enter a criminal judgment including that restitution amount. That judgment would become a judgment lien on that defendant’s real estate. Criminal restitution can never be discharged in bankruptcy. Because this debt underlying this judgment lien can’t be discharged, the resulting judgment lien cannot be “avoided” in bankruptcy.

Non-Dischargeable Debts

This could be the topic of many blog posts. But in general there are two categories of debts that are not discharged—written off—in bankruptcy. Because the underlying debt is not discharged, the resulting judgment lien on real estate cannot be “avoided”—removed.

First, certain debts are automatically not discharged. They include the following:

  • many but not all student loans
  • child support or spousal support obligations
  • divorce property settlements (except under Chapter 13)
  • criminal fines, costs, and restitution
  • some but not all income taxes and other taxes and governmental debts
  • many but not all homeowner association fees and assessments
  • death or injury caused by driving under the influence of intoxicants

Second, there are other kinds of debts that may not be discharged, but only if the creditor files an objection. It’s not automatic. In fact, if the creditor does not object to a discharge, these kinds of debts ARE discharged in bankruptcy.  The creditor must file a formal objection in bankruptcy court, do so within quite a short timetable, and then the court decides whether that the particular debt meets certain conditions.  The kinds of debt that MAY not be dischargeable include the following:

  • injury to person or property caused by a willful and malicious act, such as an assault
  • fraud used to get money, goods or services, such as by lying on a credit application or bouncing a check
  • fraud committed while acting as a fiduciary, such as by embezzlement or theft while being an executor, trustee or guardian

If the judgment does not relate to these categories, and the creditor doesn’t successfully object to discharge, then in bankruptcy you can discharge the debt underlying the judgment. If the underlying debt can be discharged, then the resulting judgment lien could also be “avoided”—permanently removed—from your home’s title.

 

A Sample Judgment Lien, Undone

January 9th, 2017 at 8:00 am

Here’s an example showing why a judgment lien on your home is dangerous, and how bankruptcy can solve this problem.   

 

The last two blog posts have been about judgment liens on a home: the trouble they cause and how bankruptcy gets rid of them.

Today we’ll give examples both of judgment lien trouble and of bankruptcy’s solution.

The Trouble Caused by a Judgment Lien

Brent and Sandra Taylor own a $290,000 home with a $250,000 mortgage. They have a lot of other debt. Besides the mortgage they owe mostly medical bills and credit cards—$80,000 and $55,000 of them, respectively, $135,000 altogether.

One collection agency collecting on $20,000 of the medical bills sued them six months ago. Brent and Sandra didn’t respond to the lawsuit. They figured they definitely owed those medical bills and so had no reason to respond or object. Plus they had nothing to offer in settlement, either as a lump sum or in monthly payments.

They didn’t realize that in their state, like in many states, a judgment automatically turns into a judgment lien on real estate owned by the judgment debtor. The collection company recently informed them there was a judgment lien on their home in the amount of $22,500. The extra amount was for the collection agency’s attorney fees and other legal costs, plus ongoing interest.

The Taylors are now getting calls from the collection agency making them believe they’re going to lose their home. They’ve gotten the impression that the judgment lien can be foreclosed on since they have enough equity in the home to cover it. They’ve been pressured to refinance or sell their home. Because of their debts and inadequate equity, they can’t qualify for any refinancing. So they think they have to sell the home.

Their Dilemma

Even if the Taylors would somehow succeed in getting refinancing, they would have to pay off the judgment lien from the refinancing proceeds.  That would just about wipe out their equity.(Again, this makes a refinancing virtually out of the question.)

Or if they would sell their home, the judgment lien would have to be paid in full out of the sale proceeds. That’s because valid judgment liens must be paid before the homeowners get anything from the property.  After paying off the judgment lien and other costs of sale, they would have very little left over to get new housing. Certainly nowhere near enough for the down payment on a home; likely barely enough for a few months of rent.

Brent and Sandra hate the whole idea of selling their home. In their housing market renting would cost more, especially when accounting for the mortgage interest tax deduction. Plus they know it would be many years before they could again qualify for a mortgage, especially with tighter financing standards these days.

Partly Saved by the Homestead Exemption

So they go to see a bankruptcy lawyer. The first thing they learn is that they are entitled to a homestead exemption that provides certain protections for their home equity.

Assume that in their state their homestead exemption amount is $50,000. (These amounts vary widely so you need to find out from an attorney how much you qualify for. Determining this can often be more complicated than you think.)

One protection that $50,000 homestead exemption provides is that the collection agency actually can’t foreclose on the judgment lien. (The collection agency purposely gave Brent and Sandra the wrong impression on this.) The collection agency can’t foreclose because Brent and Sandra have $40,000 in equity ($290,000 home value minus the $250,000 mortgage). All of that $40,000 of equity is protected by the $50,000 homestead exemption.

But that still leaves Brent and Sandra with a judgment lien, increasing over time, which would have to be paid in full whenever they sell the home. And they still also have all the rest of their debts, most of which they are far behind on. Before long will come more lawsuits, and more judgment liens.

Judgment Lien Avoidance

As explained in our last blog post, if the Taylors filed a bankruptcy case, the judgment lien could be “avoided.” It could be completely taken off their home’s title.

That’s because all of that $22,500+ judgment lien “impairs” their homestead exemption. That is, all of the equity that this judgment lien eats into is protected by the Taylor’s $50,000 homestead exemption.

The Good Conclusion

So, if they filed a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” case, most likely Brent and Sandra would be able to discharge (permanently write off) all their $135,000 or so in medical and credit card debts. They would “avoid” the $22,500+ judgment lien so it would be permanently off their home title. Because they want to keep their home they would continue owing and paying their mortgage.

But they would have no other debts, and no judgment lien. Brent and Sandra Taylor would have a fresh financial start.

 

Undoing a Judgment Lien

January 6th, 2017 at 8:00 am

Bankruptcy can do more than forever discharge your debts. It can undo some bad creditor actions, like a recorded judgment lien on your home.


If a creditor has sued and gotten a judgment against you, it likely now also has a judgment lien against your home. In our last blog post a couple of days ago, we got into how dangerous judgment liens can be. We also explained how you may have a judgment lien on your home and not even know it. Given how dangerous they can be, it’s good that bankruptcy often can destroy judgment liens.

The Benefits of Bankruptcy

Filing bankruptcy gives you four big benefits in dealing with creditor judgments and judgment liens. These benefits apply to both kinds of consumer bankruptcy—Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” and Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts.”

1. Filing bankruptcy stops the creditor from enforcing the judgment itself. It can’t start or continue garnishing your paychecks or using virtually any other methods of collecting the debt.

2. Bankruptcy also stops your creditor from enforcing the judgment lien itself by foreclosing on your home.

3. Most of the time bankruptcy results in the discharge (legal write-off) of the underlying debt.

4. Often the judgment lien itself can be gotten rid of forever through the judgment lien “avoidance” procedure. The rest of this blog post is about this important procedure.

Judgment Lien “Avoidance”

The getting rid of—“avoidance”—of a judgment lien is quite a remarkable procedure. Bankruptcy generally only discharges debts; it doesn’t get rid of liens. Bankruptcy discharges most monetary obligations; it doesn’t usually get rid of creditors’ property rights in collateral.

Consider a vehicle loan lender’s lien on your vehicle’s title. That lienholder’s lien doesn’t go away when you file bankruptcy. Instead you must satisfy the lien. You either continue making payments to keep your vehicle until the debt is satisfied and the lien is released, or deal with the lien through a Chapter 13 “cramdown” by paying off the lien. Or else you surrender the vehicle to the creditor and satisfy the lien that way.

Yet Judgment Liens Can Be “Avoided” in Bankruptcy

Judgment liens are different.

They can be “avoided”—altogether undone—in bankruptcy under certain circumstances that are often not difficult to meet.

Those circumstances involve when a judgment lien “impairs,” or eats into your homestead exemption.

A homestead exemption is a protection from creditors that the law provides for your home. It is usually expressed as a certain dollar amount of home value or home equity.

For example, assume you own a $300,000 home with a $260,000 mortgage, and so the home has $40,000 of equity. Assume also that where you reside you are allowed a $50,000 homestead exemption. That $50,000 protection from the homestead exemption is more than enough to cover the entire $40,000 of home equity.

So if a creditor sued you for $15,000 and got a judgment in that amount, it would likely record a judgment lien on your home also in that same $15,000 amount.

Because you have equity of $40,000, normally that $15,000 judgment lien would eat into that $40,000 of equity. The judgment lien would encumber $15,000 of your home equity, effectively reducing your home equity by $15,000.

But because that $15,000 of equity is protected by your homestead exemption, that judgment lien “impairs” the homestead exemption. As a result the judgment lien can be “avoided”—gotten rid of—through bankruptcy.

The Specific Conditions for Judgment Lien “Avoidance”

To be clear, here are the conditions you must meet:

  • The real estate to which the judgment lien has attached is your “homestead,” entitling you to the homestead exemption.
  • The lien must be a “judicial lien.” That’s defined in the Bankruptcy Code as “a lien obtained by judgment, levy, sequestration, or other legal or equitable process or proceeding.”
  • This “judicial lien” cannot be for child or spousal support, or for a mortgage foreclosure.
  • As described in the above example, the judgment lien at issue must “impair” the homestead exemption. The lien has to cut into the equity (or home value) protected by the applicable homestead exemption.  

Need a Motion to “Avoid” the Judgment Lien

Going through the basic bankruptcy procedure will not of itself get rid of a judgment lien. The “avoidance” requires a legal procedure dedicated specifically for that purpose. It’s usually a motion filed in the bankruptcy court by your bankruptcy lawyer. Otherwise the judgment lien would continue to attach to your home after your bankruptcy case is over.

The “avoidance” procedure needs to be done while your Chapter 7 or 13 case is active and open. Otherwise the closed case would have to be reopened. Assuming that the court allows the reopening, it would cost you hundreds of dollars more in court fees. Obviously it’s important to get it done on time.

 

The Dangerous Judgment Lien

January 4th, 2017 at 8:00 am

A judgment lien effectively converts a debt that was secured by nothing into one secured by your home. 


Has a creditor sued you and gotten a judgment against you? If so, and you own a home, most likely there is now a judgment lien against your home.

The Dangerous Judgment Lien

What’s a lien? It attaches an asset you own to a debt you owe, and secures the debt with it.

judgment lien, in most states, attaches your home to the amount you owe to the judgment-holding creditor. Usually without your consent, your home then secures that debt.

A judgment lien gives the creditor huge leverage to make you to pay the entire debt. Not only pay the debt, but also the creditor’s attorney fees, its other costs for getting the judgment against you, and its constantly accumulating interest.

If you try to sell or refinance your home, the judgment lien forces you to pay the judgment.  That debt has to be paid—usually in full—out of the sale or refinancing proceeds. It comes straight out of money you would have otherwise received. A judgment lien can sometimes also prevent you from being able to do the sale or the refinance altogether.

Under some circumstances and in many states, the creditor can foreclose on the judgment lien even if you don’t sell or refinance the home. You could lose your home if you don’t come up with a way to quickly pay off the judgment amount.

Stealth Judgment Liens

Usually you know it when you’ve been sued by a creditor. You are served with papers that make that clear.

But sometimes you are not personally served and don’t know about the lawsuit. Or you may receive papers but don’t read them closely. Or you realize you’ve been sued but then nothing seems to happen and you don’t find out what did in fact happen with the lawsuit.

If you don’t respond by the deadline stated in the papers you receive, the creditor automatically wins the lawsuit. A judgment is entered against you in the amount the creditor sued you for. A judgment lien is then placed on your home in that amount plus the creditor’s often-substantial costs.

If you are not paying attention, you could easily have no idea that the court entered a judgment against you. Even if you are paying close attention, you are not necessarily informed that a judgment has been entered. And even if you do know about the judgment, you may not find out that your home now has a lien on it in the amount of the judgment.

Judgment Liens after Settlement

You could also have a judgment lien on your home even if you closely cooperated with a creditor. Have you ever settled with a creditor, agreeing to make monthly payments on a debt? The settlement could have included the creditor’s right to enter a judgment against you. That way it doesn’t have to go through the costs and delay of suing you if you don’t make the agreed payments.

Even if a judgment was not entered at the time of the settlement, it’s standard practice that one is entered automatically if you fail to make the agreed payments on time.

These kinds of settlements can be entered into whether or not the creditor filed a lawsuit before the settlement. So, if you’ve entered into a settlement with a creditor, you could easily have a judgment lien on your home. And that could be true even if you are current on your settlement payments.

The Limitations and Benefits of Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy writes off (“discharges”) most kinds of debts, but is generally not very good at getting rid of liens. Liens are creditors’ rights against your property, rights that the bankruptcy law generally respects. For example, if you want to keep your vehicle in bankruptcy, you generally have to pay off its lienholder.

But in many situations you CAN get rid of a creditor’s judgment lien on your home. We’ll show in a couple days in our next blog post.

 

Debt Secured by Judgment Lien Can Often Be Turned into an Unsecured Debt

August 15th, 2016 at 7:00 am

A judgment lien turns an unsecured debt into one secured by a lien on your home. Bankruptcy can undo that, and write off the debt.

 

Very Different Treatment of Unsecured Debts and Secured Debts

A couple blog posts ago we discussed how differently unsecured and secured debts are treated in bankruptcy.

Most debts that do not have a “lien” on any of your property or possessions are legally, permanently written off in bankruptcy. However with secured debts the lien that the creditor has in your asset is NOT USUALLY written off or affected in any way in bankruptcy. That means the creditor can take collection action against your asset through that lien after the bankruptcy case is completed. As a result usually you have to pay the debt.

But in certain situations bankruptcy CAN turn a secured debt back into an unsecured debt. We focus on another one of those situations today.

Erase a Lien in Bankruptcy is Extraordinary

It’s important to realize how extraordinary it is to be able to turn a secured debt into an unsecured one. It’s unusual even in bankruptcy. Most liens cannot be erased. Instead, after bankruptcy they often have to be paid either in full or in part.

So it’s quite special to be able to erase a judgment lien, write off the debt, and not pay anything.

Erasing a Judgment Lien

But this can only be done under certain circumstances. The good news is that for practical reason these circumstances apply to a large percentage of people filing bankruptcy who have a judgment lien on their home.

In order to get rid of a judgment lien, the liens must “impair your homestead exemption.” (See Section 522(f) of the Bankruptcy Code).

An Example of “Impairing Your Homestead Exemption”  

Here are the conditions that have to be met, applied to a hypothetical example.

  1. The judgment lien that is being gotten rid of must be attached to your “homestead.” That is legally defined differently in different states but generally means the place where you live. So assume you live in a home titled in your name, with a mortgage—that’s your homestead. In our example it’s worth $200,000 with a $180,000 mortgage, and so has equity of $20,000.
  2. The equity in your homestead must be protected by a “homestead exemption.” State and federal laws provide different amounts of protection for your home. It’s usually described as a certain maximum dollar amount of equity. In our example assume a homestead exemption of $30,000. Since that’s more than your $20,000 in equity, all of your equity is protected by the homestead exemption.
  3. The lien being removed must be a “judicial lien.” That’s defined in the Bankruptcy Code as “a lien obtained by judgment, levy, sequestration, or other legal or equitable process or proceeding.” And that judgment lien can’t be based on child or spousal support, or a mortgage foreclosure. In our example you’ve been sued by a collection company for an unpaid $15,000 medical bill. You knew you owed the money so you didn’t respond to the lawsuit. So a judgment was entered against you, which turned into a judgment lien against your home. This is the kind of “judicial lien” that could potentially be removed in bankruptcy.
  4. That judgment lien must “impair the homestead exemption” to be able to get rid of it through bankruptcy. This generally means that the judgment lien attaches to equity that is protected by the applicable homestead exemption. In our example the $15,000 judgment lien attaches to the $20,000 in equity in the home.  ALL of that $15,000 of equity is included in the equity that is protected by the homestead exemption. So, the ENTIRE $15,000 judgment lien would be removed by filing bankruptcy. The underlying medical debt would be written off. You would owe nothing and the judgment lien would be gone.

 

“Avoiding” a Judgment Lien on Your Home in Chapter 13

July 27th, 2016 at 7:00 am

Both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 can wipe away judgment liens. But doing so under Chapter 13 can be better when used with its other benefits.  

 

In our July 1 blog post we gave a list of 10 ways that a Chapter 13 case can help you keep your home. Today we cover the 9th of those 10 ways. Here’s how we introduced this earlier.

9. Judgment Lien “Avoidance”

A judgment lien is put on your home by a creditor who sues and gets a judgment against you. It then records that judgment in the county where your home is located. (Or the creditor uses whatever procedure creates a judgment lien in your state).

In bankruptcy, a judgment lien can be removed from your home under certain circumstances. Essentially, the equity in your home that’s encumbered by the judgment lien must be covered by the applicable homestead exemption. In other words, the judgment lien must “impair” the homestead exemption. If it does, the judgment lien can be removed, or “avoided,” from the title of your home.

Judgment lien “avoidance” is available under Chapter 7 as well as Chapter 13. But Chapter 13 can be better when lien “avoidance” is used in combination with other tools only Chapter 13 provides.

Here’s how this works in practice.

The Example

Assume that you own a home that is worth $200,000. You lost your job 18 months ago and were unemployed for 12 months. As a result you fell 9 payments behind on the $1,200 monthly mortgage payments, a total of $10,800 behind. The full amount owed on the mortgage is $180,000. Your mortgage lender is threatening to foreclose on the home if you don’t quickly catch up on the missed payments.

During your unemployment you also couldn’t make the payments on a credit card with a balance of $7,500. It was sent to collection and the collection company sued you. You didn’t respond to the lawsuit because you knew you owed the money and saw no benefit to objecting. So the collection company got a default judgment against you. The amount of the judgment is $8,750, since the collector could add its costs of the lawsuit to the judgment. The collector then recorded a judgment lien against your home in that amount.

So your $200,000 home in encumbered by the $180,000 mortgage plus the $8,750 judgment. Assume also that you are entitled to a $25,000 homestead exemption.

The Judgment Lien “Avoidance” Here

Under either a Chapter 7 “straight bankruptcy” or a Chapter 13 “adjustment of debts,” this $8,750 judgment lien can be removed from your home’s title.

That’s because the equity in your home that the judgment lien is encumbering is protected by the homestead exemption.

Here’s how the math works. Without the judgment lien, there’s $20,000 in equity in the home—its $200,000 value minus the $180,000 mortgage. The $25,000 homestead exemption would protect up to $25,000 of equity. So, all of the $20,000 in equity is protected. The entire $8,750 judgment lien eats into, or “impairs,” this protected equity. And so the entire judgment lien can be “avoided,” or released from your home’s title through bankruptcy.

The Chapter 7 Possibility

If you filed a Chapter 7 case and “avoided” the judgment lien you would likely also be able to “discharge”—legally write off—that $8,750 credit card debt. The debt would be gone, and the judgment lien would be gone off your home, and the debt itself would be gone forever. Mission accomplished there.

But that still leaves you $10,800 behind on your mortgage. Discharging your other debts may leave you with some available money each month to pay towards this mortgage arrearage. If so, you might be able to make a deal with your home mortgage lender for catching up on the mortgage. If so, go for it.

However, often the amount that you could pay towards the mortgage arrearage would not be enough to satisfy your mortgage lender. Mortgage lenders in this situation often insist on homeowners catching up within 10-12 months. That’s amounts to about $1,080 to $1,200 per month under our facts. And you’d have to pay that on top of the regular ongoing monthly payments of $1,200.

You may simply not have much extra money in your budget even after a Chapter 7 case.  You may not be able to catch up on your mortgage fast enough to satisfy your mortgage lender. If so it wouldn’t do much good to “avoid” the judgment lien on your home only to lose it to a mortgage foreclosure.

The Chapter 13 Advantage

If you and your bankruptcy lawyer instead filed a Chapter 13 case, it could solve this dilemma. Your mortgage lender would be forced to give you MUCH more time to catch up on the mortgage arrearage.

A Chapter 13 payment plan usually lasts from 3 to 5 years. You are generally allowed to push it out the full 5 years in order to reduce how much you would need to pay your mortgage lender monthly.

The payment plan can often be creative by adjusting for anticipated changes in your income or expenses. You may be able to pay less on the mortgage arrearage early in the plan to deal with even more urgent debts. Sometimes you can even pay all or part of the arrearage through a later refinancing or sale of the home.

The bottom line: when you need to “avoid” a judgment lien but also need other benefits that Chapter 13 provides, look closely at that option. Chapter 13 takes much longer but those benefits may make it well worthwhile.

 

Erasing a Judgment Lien from Your Home’s Title

June 3rd, 2016 at 7:00 am

The potential ability to get rid of judgment liens from your home’s title is an impressive benefit of bankruptcy.

 

Our last blog post was about preventing a creditor from getting a judgment against you, and from getting a judgment lien on your home. Today’s is about erasing a judgment lien from your home after it has already attached.

It’s important: because of how much damage a judgment lien can cause, you can greatly help yourself by filing a bankruptcy case either to stop a judgment lien from attaching to your home or to erase one that has attached earlier.

The Damage Caused by a Judgment Lien

A judgment lien can turn a debt you owe that is unsecured—does not legally attach to anything you own—into a secured debt—secured by what you own, such as your home. So the existence of a judgment lien can take a debt that you can discharge—fully and permanently write off in bankruptcy—into a debt that you must pay in full. And until it is paid, it can haunt you and your home for many years.

Judgment liens are dangerous for lots of reasons. They eat up equity in your home, potentially jeopardize your efforts to refinance or sell it, and seriously hurt your credit. The judgment creditor may even be able to foreclose on its judgment lien, resulting in a forced sale of your home to pay the judgment debt.

Clearly, if you have already been sued, have a judgment against you and a judgment lien on your home’s title, erasing that judgment lien would be a valuable benefit of bankruptcy.

Unusual to Erase a Lien in Bankruptcy

Most kinds of secured debts can’t be turned into unsecured debts in bankruptcy. Most liens cannot be erased. A vehicle lender’s lien on your vehicle’s title, or your home mortgage lender’s mortgage on your home’s title, remain on those titles after bankruptcy. If you want to keep your vehicle or your home, you generally have to agree to keep on paying their debts. The liens don’t go away until the debts are paid off, as long as you choose to keep the vehicle or the home.

This is true not just with voluntary liens such as these, but also many involuntary liens, such as income tax liens. Liens generally survive bankruptcy.

So be aware how unusual it is, even in bankruptcy, to be able to erase a judgment lien.

The Conditions for Erasing—or “Avoiding”—a Judgment Lien

It can only be done under certain circumstances. However, these circumstances apply to a large percentage of people filing bankruptcy who have a judgment lien on their home.

In order to get rid of—“avoid”—a judgment lien, that liens must “impair your homestead exemption.” (See Section 522(f) of the Bankruptcy Code).

Here’s what that means:  

  1. The judgment lien that is being “avoided” must be attached to your “homestead.” That is defined differently in different states but generally refers to the place where you live.
  2. The equity in that homestead must be protected by a “homestead exemption.” State and federal laws provide different amounts of protection for your home, usually described as a certain maximum dollar amount of equity. These amounts vary quite drastically among the states—from about $5,000 of equity to an unlimited amount.
  3. The lien to be “avoided” can’t just be any kind of lien but must be a “judicial lien,” defined in the Bankruptcy Code as “a lien obtained by judgment, levy, sequestration, or other legal or equitable process or proceeding.”
  4. To be “avoided” the “judicial lien” can’t be based on child or spousal support, or be for a mortgage foreclosure.
  5. The judgment lien at issue must “impair the homestead exemption,” which generally means that the equity that the judgment lien attaches to is equity that is protected by the applicable homestead exemption. That generally means that without accounting for the judgment lien the amount of equity in the home does not exceed the homestead exemption.

For example, assume your home has equity (before accounting for the judgment lien) of $25,000. Also assume that your state’s homestead exemption is $30,000, so all of the $25,000 of equity would be protected by this homestead exemption. If you’d have a $10,000 judgment lien against your home, all of that $10,000 lien would be eating into that portion of the equity that is protected by the homestead exemption. Since the entire judgment lien “impairs the homestead exemption,” all of that lien can be “avoided”—erased through bankruptcy.

 

Call today for a FREE Consultation

210-342-3400

Facebook Blog
Back to Top Back to Top